The Unwritten Agreements

On character, conscience, and the exceptions we make for ourselves

Every time I get into my car, I place an astonishing amount of trust in complete strangers.
I've seen drivers applying mascara in the rearview mirror, reading the newspaper spread across the steering wheel, and once, a man shaving with an electric razor at 65 miles an hour. Apparently getting ready for work now includes the commute.
The guy with the razor stuck with me. He was counting on everyone else to pay attention while he concentrated on his stubble.
And then there are those two-lane roads where the only thing between me and an oncoming car is a painted yellow line. That's it. Paint. Yet I trust complete strangers to stay on their side, just as they trust me to stay on mine.
So much of civilized life depends on unspoken agreements like this, most of which have never been written down. We take turns, respect other people's property, tell the truth, and generally try not to make life miserable for one another.
Or at least that's the idea.
Lately I've been thinking about character. I don't mean reputation, or the version of ourselves we show the world. I mean who we are when nobody's paying attention.
Most of us consider ourselves reasonably decent people. Honest. Compassionate. Fair. Loyal. But do we love those values enough to live by them?
Say there's a case of bottled water on the bottom of my grocery cart. The cashier doesn't notice it, but I do. I can point it out, or I can walk away with my complimentary water. After all, the cashier made the mistake. Not me.
Or my neighbor's Amazon package lands on my porch. I open it and find six pairs of socks. Amazon will replace them, and my neighbor will eventually get another package. And who couldn't use six more pairs of socks?
Then there's the cashier who gives me too much change. Maybe she ought to pay closer attention.
See how easily the responsibility slides over to someone else? I'm not stealing, I'm just benefiting from another person's carelessness. I'm not dishonest, I'm being practical.
Psychologists call some of this moral disengagement: we minimize the consequences, shift the blame, or convince ourselves our circumstances justify an exception. We're remarkably good at it.
Now consider what happens when the person making exceptions holds real power.
Politicians, corporate executives, clergy, police officers, and immigration enforcement agents all hold authority that comes with serious ethical responsibility. When that authority is abused, the consequences can be devastating, especially for people who have little power to push back.
In psychotherapy, we're acutely aware of power differentials. A client trusts a therapist with their vulnerabilities, and that trust creates an ethical responsibility. It's never an opportunity for personal gain. The same principle ought to apply wherever one person holds power over another.
Of course, these abuses aren't in the same league as walking out of the grocery store with an unpaid case of water. But they raise a related question: How do we square our actions with the principles we claim to hold? And what happens when institutions start making excuses for the people who misuse their authority?
When the people entrusted with keeping the rules keep finding ways around them, the rest of us may start wondering why we should bother. If they're getting away with it, why shouldn't I?
There's something odd about letting people whose behavior we disapprove of set our standards for us.
And we're often willing to excuse dishonesty when it comes from someone we admire or agree with. Loyalty turns out to be a complicated virtue. At what point does standing by someone turn into making excuses for them?
Some people blame the decline of organized religion for society's apparent loss of moral direction. Religious communities have certainly helped pass along values and a sense of responsibility toward others. But religious belief has never guaranteed good character, and the absence of religion doesn't mean the absence of conscience.
Nor am I convinced people were more virtuous in the good old days. History offers plenty of evidence to the contrary.
Maybe the better question is whether we take the work of developing our character seriously, wherever our moral or spiritual beliefs come from.
I've spent much of my professional life helping people identify the values they want to live by. In Acceptance and Commitment Therapy, values aren't destinations we arrive at. They're directions we choose. I think of them as a North Star.
Not that I always follow mine. I've had plenty of uncharitable thoughts, impatient responses, and moments when my principles might have taken the day off.
But a North Star is useful precisely because we wander. It helps us notice when we've drifted from the person we want to be.
There's also a difference between believing in a value and loving it. Believing in honesty means I think honesty matters. Loving honesty means I care when I betray it. Living honestly means making the effort to act on it, even when nobody would know the difference.
Maybe working on our character is just the ongoing business of noticing the gap between what we believe and what we do and trying to close it.
Which brings me back to that yellow line.
Every day we trust strangers to honor an agreement we've never discussed. Most of them do. And they’re trusting me to do the same.
I wonder how many other parts of our shared lives depend on agreements just as important, and a lot easier to ignore. And how much of what we call character is simply our willingness to keep them when nobody's watching.
Including, apparently, when there's a case of bottled water on the bottom of the cart.
Janet Nash, MSW, LISW-S, is a psychotherapist, yoga therapist, and writer who explores the complexities, contradictions, and occasional absurdities of being human.



